My theory is that they are actually in Neverland from peter pan. I mean with the pirates and weird shit going on. What if peter pan was actually based on a real thing, what if the "others" were really stranded 200 year old pirates (from the black rock) and everybody else were the "lost boys". It all makes sense. I just wanted to call this now and get it in writing so when im right i can tell you i told you so. Mike loves this theory
